Astronomy Acceptances
Astronomy Acceptances
Hey guys,
I'm getting tired of wading through all of the physics grad school posts for news on Astronomy/Astrophysics schools. I think it's high time we started our own thread (not that people should stop posting on those threads, I'd just like to get our own little discussion going here).
I've heard so far from Boulder, Arizona and Hawaii and I know that sadpanda has heard from UW Madison. Anyone else?
I'm getting tired of wading through all of the physics grad school posts for news on Astronomy/Astrophysics schools. I think it's high time we started our own thread (not that people should stop posting on those threads, I'd just like to get our own little discussion going here).
I've heard so far from Boulder, Arizona and Hawaii and I know that sadpanda has heard from UW Madison. Anyone else?
-
- Posts: 73
- Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 3:16 pm
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2007 12:02 am
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 11:13 pm
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 11:13 pm
Seattle Vs. Honolulu
According to salary.com, the cost of living is over $6,000/year more, but the increase in stipend covers that and then some. Interesting site--I'll be using that to compare financial offers when (fingers crossed) I have more than one
According to salary.com, the cost of living is over $6,000/year more, but the increase in stipend covers that and then some. Interesting site--I'll be using that to compare financial offers when (fingers crossed) I have more than one
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 11:13 pm
Last edited by DwightSchrute on Wed Feb 13, 2008 8:44 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Yahoo Neighborhoods seems to have more locations than Salary.com, and you can just type in a city name or zip code instead of looking in a drop down menu:
http://realestate.yahoo.com/neighborhoods
http://realestate.yahoo.com/neighborhoods
shouravv, I heard from Hawaii on Tues night (by phone).
Great advice on places to check for living expenses guys. I've been too busy obsessively checking my e-mail to think about practical concerns like that.
DwightSchrute: I'm still waiting on Madison, Chicago, Berkeley and Harvard. Anyone heard from any of those other than Madison?
Great advice on places to check for living expenses guys. I've been too busy obsessively checking my e-mail to think about practical concerns like that.
DwightSchrute: I'm still waiting on Madison, Chicago, Berkeley and Harvard. Anyone heard from any of those other than Madison?
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 11:13 pm
These are the most "straight forward" graduate school rankings that I've seen online. It is based on the NRC rankings from 1995; however, the actual document was created by folks at Berkeley. Take it for what its worth.
http://www.grad.berkeley.edu/publicatio ... s_1995.pdf
http://www.grad.berkeley.edu/publicatio ... s_1995.pdf
-
- Posts: 73
- Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 3:16 pm
Also I do not know if its really of any use to know the top 10-15 programs in a field. These are typically very familiar names and hard to get into. Personally I choose research over ranking any day. There's no point in applying to a top 10 program if they dont do the research your interested in pursuing.
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 11:13 pm
In 1995 the dot com era was coming into full swing and AOL was the hottest stock around. Harvard, on the other hand, has been an icon of the educational system since before our parents were born. Point being, collegiate reputations are relatively stable and not nearly as volatile as news found in the Wall Street Journal. I'd place a bet that all 10 schools mentioned in the link posted still have highly reputable astronomy programs, even thought the idea of ranking graduate programs in a strict hierarchy is a bit absurd and also noting that there might have been slight movements up or down the charts for a few institutions. To many, knowledge of the top 10 schools isn't very useful because of their overly high standards of admission; However, to those who have received, or will receive, admission offers to schools listed in the top 10 (Princeton, UT Austin, etc.), seeing their institution listed may provide a bit of satisfaction and a sense of accomplishment.
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Tue Feb 05, 2008 11:13 pm
true, but if you look at faculty profiles and note where the professors received their Ph.D.'s at nearly any reputable school (say, top 100), you might notice a bit of redundancy. And that redundancy also seems to be a bit correlated with school rankings. Rankings are hardly a definitive source of information, but they're also not just pulled out of a hat.
I guess that makes me feel better...After everything is said and done you should get a letter formally rejecting you. It is, after all, the least they can do. If you don't get anything it probably means you're waitlisted.
Though, I think the school I am interested in is just lazy in sending out their rejection letters.
-
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 4:35 pm
I was accepted to Ohio State astronomy in late January, and got an offer from the University of Arizona last week
Congratulations to everyone on their acceptances and strength to those still waiting! phys007, your list is impressive, I'm waiting to hear from Cornell, too, and would be rather interested in your stats
Congratulations to everyone on their acceptances and strength to those still waiting! phys007, your list is impressive, I'm waiting to hear from Cornell, too, and would be rather interested in your stats
To be honest, my stats aren't all that impressive, which is why I've been hesitant to post them here (that and I'm a wee bit paranoid). This is just a guess, but I think my strongest portion was my statement of purpose and possibly recommendation letters, which doesn't really come across in a list of GPA and GRE scores. I tried to emphasize that my past research is similar to what other schools are doing, and basically went for a holistic 'fit' rather than a summary of my accomplishments.
I read somewhere (on the internet, so it has to be true) that since women tend to score lower on standardized tests, grad schools looked at overall fit more for them. I feel like that's probably true in my case- the old advice that a SOP can only hurt you if it's terrible but won't help your chances might not be entirely accurate.
I read somewhere (on the internet, so it has to be true) that since women tend to score lower on standardized tests, grad schools looked at overall fit more for them. I feel like that's probably true in my case- the old advice that a SOP can only hurt you if it's terrible but won't help your chances might not be entirely accurate.
i think the SOP is one of the most important things in our field. unless you have perfect grades and gre scores, in which case you'll probably get in most places, the SOP is the only way to highlight your best qualities and this taken in conjunction with your letters of rec which all ties in with your research experience seem to me to be the most important things. this is my second year applying. i've had more success this year and i attribute that to my SOP, which is the only thing that has really changed from last year.
-
- Posts: 73
- Joined: Sun Dec 30, 2007 3:16 pm
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2007 12:02 am
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2007 12:02 am
@tnoviell
It is not that I do not want to share my stats, but I do have objections to posting personal information on the net. I did in a different forum (non-scientific), and I was identified with just little info and the people took it a bit too far!
What I believe is important to other people is that they know Harvard is already notifying people. They should assess their chances based on that. I do believe that admission to graduate school is a personal process that should be approached stratigically, and that one CANNOT asses their chances based on what others did.
I have a friend who got accepted to Harvard a few years ago. Only one A in an upper physics class: the rest just A- and mostly B+s, Bs, and B-s. His GRE physics was dismall: lower 25 percentile. BUT he was an OUTSTANDING researcher. If he put his stats here everybody will think he is crazy by applying.
Good luck everybody!
It is not that I do not want to share my stats, but I do have objections to posting personal information on the net. I did in a different forum (non-scientific), and I was identified with just little info and the people took it a bit too far!
What I believe is important to other people is that they know Harvard is already notifying people. They should assess their chances based on that. I do believe that admission to graduate school is a personal process that should be approached stratigically, and that one CANNOT asses their chances based on what others did.
I have a friend who got accepted to Harvard a few years ago. Only one A in an upper physics class: the rest just A- and mostly B+s, Bs, and B-s. His GRE physics was dismall: lower 25 percentile. BUT he was an OUTSTANDING researcher. If he put his stats here everybody will think he is crazy by applying.
Good luck everybody!
physicsstudent, it's fine. People here just like seeing them for other purposes, and people from next year may want to make a sort of comparison, as it can be useful for some folks. I'm already in grad school myself so it's not for my own sake, but mainly for the future folk of the forum. But, it's entirely your choice regardless.
@tnoviell
i think i read in one of the posts that you are at Johns Hopkins, have they completed their first wave of acceptances. i dont know if they keep you guys in the loop or not, but I was kinda curious cos none of the ppl who've applied to the astro portion of the dept seem to have heard anything back from the dept yet.
i think i read in one of the posts that you are at Johns Hopkins, have they completed their first wave of acceptances. i dont know if they keep you guys in the loop or not, but I was kinda curious cos none of the ppl who've applied to the astro portion of the dept seem to have heard anything back from the dept yet.
-
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Thu Feb 07, 2008 8:06 pm
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2007 12:02 am
@littlemonster
I am going to visit the two places and then decide which is best. I have not decided yet, BUT I will make sure to let UW know as soon as I do decide not to go there. I will be thrilled to know that the spot will go to you or someone else in the list.
Are you on the waiting list? Did they inform you of that?
Best wishes to you!
ps
I am going to visit the two places and then decide which is best. I have not decided yet, BUT I will make sure to let UW know as soon as I do decide not to go there. I will be thrilled to know that the spot will go to you or someone else in the list.
Are you on the waiting list? Did they inform you of that?
Best wishes to you!
ps
-
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Thu Feb 07, 2008 8:06 pm
@ ps
yep, I got an email a few weeks after the acceptances/rejections went out saying I was at the top of their waitlist, so I've had my fingers crossed that one of the luckier people would open up a spot for me. But you're absolutely correct in visiting both and picking the better fit. I'm really happy for you, you must be having one hell of a day today!
yep, I got an email a few weeks after the acceptances/rejections went out saying I was at the top of their waitlist, so I've had my fingers crossed that one of the luckier people would open up a spot for me. But you're absolutely correct in visiting both and picking the better fit. I'm really happy for you, you must be having one hell of a day today!
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2007 12:02 am
@littlemonster
I still cannot believe I got accepted I am really worried that someone will wake me up from this dream. I did not expect to be accepted to both of my top choices this early!
I WILL keep you in mind. I will let them know my decision ASAP, but when they let you in just remeber me and smile
I still cannot believe I got accepted I am really worried that someone will wake me up from this dream. I did not expect to be accepted to both of my top choices this early!
I WILL keep you in mind. I will let them know my decision ASAP, but when they let you in just remeber me and smile